Ellington Board of Selectmen Awards School Project to Silver/Petrucelli

The board rejected the recommendation of the Permanent Building Committee to go with Moser Pilon Nelson and voted to go with the other firm.

On Tuesday night, the Board of Selectmen voted to award the contract for architectural and consultant services for the  and to Silver/Petrucelli, rejecting the .

After rejecting a motion, with four of the six members voting no, that would have awarded the contract to Moser Pilon Nelson – the – the board voted 4-2 to award the project to Silver/Petrucelli.

The four members who voted no on the first motion were the same four who voted yes on the second motion.

Let Patch save you time. Get great local stories like this delivered right to your inbox or smartphone every day with our free newsletter. Simple, fast sign-up here.

Before the decision was made, First Selectman Maurice Blanchette reminded everyone that whatever the outcome, that they should respect the efforts of the PBC and that they need to remind themselves that they need a strong PBC to shepherd these projects over the next several years.

Just prior to the first motion being voted on, Selectman Leo Miller said that he couldn’t support the motion.

“I’m just not comfortable at this point, I still have questions,” he said. “I’m perplexed at this point.”

After the motion was voted on and the PBC’s recommendation was rejected, the question then became what to do. PBC Vice Chairman Gary Magnuson said that in his opinion, the options were to give the project back to the PBC – which they didn’t want to happen, hire CREC (Capital Region Education Council), or hire Silver/Petrucelli.

He said that he feels sufficient work was done by the PBC and that he knew there would be commentary from other boards and the public.

“I’m comfortable with decision I’ve made and the vote I’ve made and I’ll stand behind that vote,” he said.

The other PBC members stood behind Magnuson.

The second motion was then voted on and the decision was made.

After the meeting, Dean Petrucelli, Vice President of Silver/Petrucelli, said that his expectation coming into the meeting was a fair and honest selection. He also said that you learn that there’s no such thing as a guarantee or expectation and that he’s seen situations like this before.

“I wouldn’t say this out of the ordinary,” Petrucelli said. “We would prefer them not to be this complex, but after you make your living doing this, you surely see the full gamut of struggles that municipalities go through on selections.”

Hugh Pearson from Moser Pilon Nelson said that in his mind, this was clearly one of the possible options.

“Every town goes through certain gyrations and has their own political function and meandering through a process,” he said. “I’ve never seen it quite like this and Ellington is not usually like this – it is a little more unique than what most people go through. But it is what it is, the people have spoken. I knew ahead of time that this was clearly one of the options that could be happening. It’s weird but we’ll win a job now and again and we’ll lose a few now and again, that’s just the way it is.”

Blanchette once again mentioned the dedicated volunteers on the boards and committees and knows that there are some bruised feelings due to the passion the members have.

He said that it was clear to him that the board had to make a decision that would bring this to a final point and that it couldn’t just wait.

“We couldn’t wait and still hope to have the same plans enacted for the same rough price,” he said. “We could have had a one-year delay if we only lost a couple months. There was a certain urgency here. Having taken the first motion not to accept the recommendation of the Permanent Building Committee, I’m glad that they took that second motion because otherwise, we could have had the worst of all worlds.”

Gil V August 30, 2012 at 12:27 AM
Again, excellent investigative reporting. Saved out town some real cash. Thank you.
DT August 30, 2012 at 12:18 PM
You're going to get what you pay for!
Lou Corsino August 30, 2012 at 01:40 PM
All proposals had to meet the towns requirements so yes we will get what we asked for but for $600k less. If the project runs over cost we have $600k until we hit the bid of MPN. If the MPN bid ran over we already wasted $600k by choosing them. All bids submitted had to meet the towns requirements for the project so not sure what MPN was doing that cost $600k more. I'm glad to see there are some people with common sense in town. It goes a long way knowing we have officials that are looking at these projects closely when they want the citizens to support a new project in town.
Patricia August 30, 2012 at 02:20 PM
I'm not sure that was the right decision. Has this company been researched? What are other projects they worked on turned out. Think about it I can get a $1.00 sandwich Or pay a little more a get a great sandwich. I'm wondering why the difference in costs? This gives me a bad feeling that we may have shot ourselves in the foot.
Lou Corsino August 30, 2012 at 06:51 PM
That's why they have a bidding process. If a company does not meet the requirements in the proposal, they are eliminated. If they have a shady history, they could be eliminated on that basis. It seems in this case that there were at least 4 proposals that were vetted and that met the requients of the proposal and there were no other reasons to eliminate the other proposals (such as bad company history, history of delays or cost overruns, etc.). So it seems that it came down to cost and there were no reasons given why the $600k was a better choice than the lowest bid except for the statement from Stomberg that said they were chosen because the town was more comfortable with them due to past projects That's not a substantive reason in a bidding process to eliminate a lower bid. It will be interesting to see how the project progresses though. There will be issues as with any project so with either bid there will be bumps along the way.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »